← P6 Nan Hua 2024 Prelim Paper 1 · Paper 12024 / P6 Nan Hua 2024 Prelim Paper 1 · Paper 1 / Question 28b

Question 28b

The table below shows the number of books read by a group of students in a week. The number of students who read 3 and 4 or more books is not shown. Each statement below is either true, false or not possible to tell from the information given. For each statement, pick a tick (✓) in the correct column. (b) Given that 2/5 of the students read at least 2 books in a week, the number of students who read 3 books was the greatest.

Question 28b diagram

Answer: False

Workings

Independently corrected solution; the supplied PDF conclusion is wrong.

Students reading fewer than 2 books = 50 + 70 = 120. This is 3/5 of all students, since 2/5 read at least 2 books.

Total students = 120 ÷ 3 × 5 = 200. Students reading at least 2 books = 2/5 × 200 = 80.

Students reading 3 or 4 or more books together = 80 − 30 = 50. Therefore at most 50 students read exactly 3 books, but 70 read 1 book. The 3-book category cannot have the greatest frequency. The statement is false, not impossible to tell.